You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Picture a Day - Its rainy!

in Picture A Day17 days ago

Now, I realize that first WW is very far in the past for today's young. More than 100 years ago. I wonder how they see it? If they find it relevant at all?

It is hard-hard-easy question. On one hand: they dont give a flying f....k! On another hand... I am not sure - does another hand exist at all in this question :/

Right now, exactly last month, my babygirl had this topic within her History lessons (beginning of XX century, WW1, Russian revolution of 1917 etc etc etc). I feel these topics to be urgent and very important (especially in comparison with other history lessons, cause this is what affected the modern history of my poor country SO MUCH!).

I looked into her history textbook; it is frankly bad, it overloads one's mind with a flood of unnecessary names, dates, events - and deprives this entire data array of any cause-and-effect relationships, turns it into tightly compressed and difficult to understand ancient garbage, dusty noise that you want to forget as soon as possible, because.. why should you fill your head with unnecessary, irrelevant, long-dead matter?..

Another important consideration (not specifically related to our youth). Generally speaking, Russians' attitude to WW1 after it ended turned out to be different from that of other Europeans. The reason was not exactly that the war was lost and ended with the shameful separate Brest-Litovsk peace treaty with Germany. This is because WW1 was waged by Imperial Russia, the Imperial army - both were destroyed during the war and then, with the total change of the country's political structure and new Bolshevik ideology - the war was included in the category of "horrific heritage of tsarism". This war was not something to be proud of, they tried to forget it as quickly as possible. No monuments were erected to the war heroes, cemeteries with soldiers were abandoned (and even destroyed, plowed up!), etc. etc. I understand very well that one needs to know his own history, but... alas.

Sort:  

Wow! How narrow of me. When I asked this question I was looking at it from my point of view, from my historical perspective. Of course it's different for Russia.

Let me start this response by saying I have been fascinated with history my whole life. I even received an award at high school graduation for interest (not excellence!) in history. Your comment allows me to reach across the globe, and time, with fresh eyes. While you weren't there when it happened, you are there now and live with the consequences, as I do. Although to many people the war seems irrelevant, you and I know it changed the world.

Of all the things that came out of that war, I think the most compelling is what it teaches us about war. A monster without a master. Those European powers ambled into the conflict without a hint of where it would take them, what it would cost.

Of course I ended up teaching history, for a few years. In many cases I put aside the book with its dusty lessons. I relearned it every year, so I could teach it fresh. I tried not to be narrow in my understanding. Your comment is a reminder that narrowness is a threat no matter how careful I try to be.

Fascinating comment. Thanks @qwerrie.

I have been fascinated with history my whole life.

Me too. Never worked as a teacher, but - during recent years - I was getting thoughts that I could and even should do that > for the sake of educating students of important things. Maybe it happened exactly this way in some alternative universe with another me! at least I wish so 😄

A monster without a master.

Sic! The more I learn history, the more I am convinced that "everything goes the wrong way", always ... that people are idiots, that violence cannot build anything fruitful but only causes extra violence, etc. I want to say "people! study history better!!!" - but I understand the problem is not there - but in the fact that power and money corrupt even decent people, when they are at the top of the pyramid, they mutate irreversibly and begin to make same mistakes, as if from a scratch. meh...